Saturday, September 28, 2013

Lost in the Desert: Rick Bass, ALL THE LAND TO HOLD US

Rick Bass' new novel manages to overcome frustrating structural issues with its elegantly clotted language and a strong sense of the tragic dualities of human desire. The narrative is all over the place-- 80 pages of one set of characters, 100 pages of another, then back to the first set, then combining the two and introducing others to boot-- and so slow-moving that the first half utterly fails to build momentum. It's not just the absence of plot: the prose and themes are also repetitive, beating the reader over the head with "desert as metaphor for the human condition," and lingering so long on description of the beauty and deadliness of the milieu that the reader's initial awe gives way to irritation. But the second half, though still longer than it needs to be, moves at a more reasonable pace and has more emotional variety, so that the self-regarding intensity of the language becomes a virtue rather than a drawback. And even in the rougher patches there are extraordinary scenes that capture perfectly the way those who build lives in inhospitable places are but a reflection of the universal urge toward dangerous yet deeply satisfying experience. Bass writes, "What was it about a desert landscape, he wondered, that produced such needs and appetites, such oversized dreamers and flash-in-the-pan pretenders?" But of course those dreamers and pretenders are no different from the rest of us, except that the scope of their dreams and pretensions is greater, and therefore ideal fodder for a gifted novelist's imperfect yet unforgettable creation.

No comments:

Post a Comment